Frequently Asked Questions

Question:
Why should I choose New York Central Mutual to be my insurance company?

Answer:
We are a company that has been known for our excellent customer service and our great rates for the past 100 years. We work hard with over 900 of the best independent insurance agents located within New York State to personally help you find the right insurance coverage. The following are just a few of the reasons that you should choose NYCM:
  • Save up to 35% on your homeowners policy and 30% on your auto policy with a variety of discounts available.
  • 24-hour customer service center ready to answer your questions anytime.
  • Payments can be made online with the use of a credit card or checking to make the process more convenient for you.
  • 24-hour claim service designed to settle your claim quickly and without hassle. We pride ourselves in the human touch. You will always talk to a person...not a machine.
  • The insured lobby option enables you to check on your account status, submit a payment, submit a claim, and much more! Register today!
  • We also offer a new On-Track Payment option making monthly payments automatic and leaving you worry free.
  • Our new Boxcar Billing feature consolidates all your insurance bills into one, easy to pay, statement.
  • Quality Repair Shop Program to get your damaged car fixed as soon as possible.

Click here to find out what our customers are saying!